Latest Headlines
- Cat Country 98.7 Is The 2024 CMA Radio Station Of The Year (With Gallery)
- Gonzalez Man Gets Two Life Sentences For Abusing Children
- One Airlifted After Highway 97 Rear End Crash
- Semi, Pickup Crash Closes Highway 29 For Hours In Cantonment
- Now That Matt Gaetz Has Resigned After Being Picked For Trump’s AG, Who Will Seek His Seat?
- Learn How To Break Down A Chicken At The Molino Library
- Escambia Man Dies In Two Vehicle Crash
- Flomaton Man Arrested In Atmore For Possession of Fentanyl, Cocaine
- Escambia Man Sentenced to 25 Years for Fentanyl Trafficking
- Tate High Softball’s Kara Wine Signs With The University of South Alabama
School Prayer Bill Clears First Hurdle
April 15, 2011
A bill permitting prayers at school events such as graduations or assemblies cleared the Senate Education Pre-K-12 Committee on a unanimous vote Thursday.
The bill sponsored by Sen. Gary Siplin, D-Orlando allows school districts to adopt policies regarding the “delivery of inspirational messages, including prayers” at graduation ceremonies or other “noncompulsory student assemblies.”
Only students could deliver the prayers and the language must be nonsectarian, the bill says.
David Barkey, an attorney with the Anti-Defamation League, said the specificity of the bill, including the use of the word “prayer” violates state and federal constitutional requirements that prohibit the endorsement of one religious philosophy by the government. And by stipulating what can be said in a prayer, that would require school involvement to police it, Barkey said.
Even with the nod from the Senate committee, the bill’s future is murky. A similar bill in the House has not yet been heard by a single committee.
By The News Service of Florida
Comments
7 Responses to “School Prayer Bill Clears First Hurdle”
REGARDING:
” the language must be nonsectarian”
&
“God help us, Amen”
Insufficiently nonsectarian. After all it uses the name “God” which a Jehovah’s Witness and a Muslim–among many different sects–would agree was unacceptable since it‘s not the name THEY use. It also uses the word “Amen” which usage is limited to Jews and Christians, leaving out all the other sects.
Any restrictions on manner of worship are restrictions on practice of religion. Those restrictions are wrong (also unconstitutional since they involve “law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereo;”) and bound to create problems. It doesn’t matter if we agree or disagree with how others are doing it, ’tain’t none of our business.
But we will insist on making it our business….
David prophesying problems
“Nonsectarian”? How can anyone of any faith that truely believes his, or her, con-
viction to that particular faith are based on actual fact pray a “nonsectarian” prayer?
How can one pray a prayer from the heart that pleases all religious beliefs? It very
simply cannot be done. This appeals to only the “politically correct” that have no
tollarance for any belief other than their own. What is that belief? GOD only knows!
Who are they trying to kid? Public prayer is proselytizing. That’s why they reject moments of silence – it’s not as effective.
People should have the right to pray anywhere and at any time they feel need.
Separation of church and state, I am 100% positive that if someone decided to lead in Muslim prayer people would stand on their heads about it and want prayer out of school functions
I dont see why people can’t just pray to themselves, you can do that all day everyday all you want. No need to broadcast it everywhere you go
More religions than christianity use the word “prayer”. So does that mean no religion can “pray” according to this debate? It is my opinion that there are many more constructive ways to use the money that is being spent on this insanity. Use the money to put back into the classrooms so that it will benefit all students. The money spent already for this could have paid for several programs and teacher salaries. I agree that school is not the place for promotion of any religion. The home is where that should take place since it is a personal issue. The ones screaming the loudest are probably the ones who need to take a look at what is going on in their own backyard!!!
How about … “God help us, Amen”